Time To Scrap WALGA And Start Again

Originally posted by Ian Ker on his Vincent Blogspot – 11 November 2014

Time and time again, during this chaotic and drawn-out so-called reform process, WALGA has embarrassed itself and the local government sector by not adequately reflecting the views of local Councils. We shall probably never know the extent to which this is the result of Troy Pickard’s imposing himself on the organisation, but it is clear that any supposedly representative organisation that doesn’t reflect the diversity of views held by its members is not serving their interests.

WALGA has consistently supported the amalgamation thrust without acknowledging that many of its members oppose it.

Of late, WALGA pronouncements appear to align more with the state government and keeping its process on track than on making sure the outcome is sensible and supported. It almost seems as though the apparent chastisement of the state government for providing inadequate funding for the process is a smoke-screen to draw attention away from WALGA’s sycophancy.

The WALGA model, with zones and State Council, is yet another example of systematic concentration of power at the expense of diversity and democracy.

Each Council is part of a WALGA Zone. Each zone considers an issue and ‘instructs’ its delegates to State Council, where WALGA policy is determined.

It is easy to see how this model can lead to perverse or undemocratic outcomes. In the case of local government so-called reform, the western suburbs councils and Vincent are all but one of the members of the Central Zone (the other being the City of Perth). The Central Zone, therefore, might be expected to have a large majority view against amalgamations.

Other metropolitan zones are likely to be more evenly split between potential ‘winners’ and ‘losers’.

So we can easily have a majority of zones, but a minority of councils, in favour of amalgamations.

Perhaps scrapping WALGA would be a step too far, although the City of Nedlands seems to be faring quite well without it, but it clearly needs to change and become more representative of the diversity of views held by its members.

In the case of local government reform, I wonder how long it will take for the representatives of non-metropolitan councils to catch up with the admirable and realistic position adopted by the National Party.

2 thoughts on “Time To Scrap WALGA And Start Again

  1. It is not only the amalgamation issues that are of concern as thorough research will show tha effectively WALGA is a ” Union” for the Shires on its books. They are NOT here to assist the a Ratepayer despite their lies. They make money from defending the illegal and corruptive dealings of the shires ( they are the ones lifting the rug for the dirt to get swept under) . A recent probity audit found severe problems with their tendering process, but where was this advertised? They not only need to be canned but also investigated by the CCC.

  2. Well written article. This association has so many flaws, it is unusual that a local government minister has not been able to gain political traction on this private organisation that is growing rapidly and creating community angst. . One needs to question who is policing this western Australian grown, (Council can endorsed) legal misconduct. We have 35 years of council and government compliance (shire of Wyndham east Kimberley and shire of dalwallinu ) and can’t believe walga personal can intimate (threatening ) our organisation with their inbuilt misconduct. On eastern seaboard, I.C.A.C is established, but W.A , no such thing! One needs to ask serious questions on the integrity of Senior council staff fleeing to the west and how our councillor’s are selected (groomed) and paid.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s